The Ethical Justification of the Thesis that Separates Law from Morality Through John Austin

Main Article Content

Galvão Rabelo

Abstract

The british legal philosopher John Austin stands at the threshold of the evolution of the legal positivist tradition. His work, which dates back to the first half of the 19th century, was especially important to establish the basic elements of this school of legal understanding. Among his contributions to the legal positivist doctrine, lies the creation of the thesis that separates morality from law. Under an ethical context, however, John Austin was an ardent utilitarian who defended the use of the principle of utility as the only rational criteria for the unveiling of superior moral standards (divine laws). Considering both dimensions of his understanding, it has long been wondered if his utilitarian ethics have influenced, somehow, his legal theory, especially in regards to the separation thesis. Said thesis, which is in the center of the legal positivist tradition, has been interpreted in different ways in contemporary legal debate. A particular branch, called ethical positivism, opened new perspectives to the study of this tradition, defending the legal positivism theory as a morally satisfactory theoretical model for the contemporary legal systems. Hence, using the main premise of ethical positivism (which states that there are moral reasons to defend the separation thesis) as an interprative and methodological tool, this paper plans on revisiting the link between John Austins legal and ethical convictions, in order to comprehend what were the moral reasons which led him to defend the separation of what law is and what it should be.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Rabelo, G. (2015). The Ethical Justification of the Thesis that Separates Law from Morality Through John Austin. Revista Brasileira De Filosofia Do Direito, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.26668/IndexLawJournals/2526-012X/2015.v1i1.819
Section
Artigos
Author Biography

Galvão Rabelo, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais - UFMG, Minas Gerais.

Mestre em Teoria do Direito pela Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Minas Gerais - PUC/Minas, Minas Gerais (2016). Mestrando na área de Direito Penal, Filosofia do Direito e interdisciplinaridade na Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais - UFMG, Minas Gerais.

References

ABBAGNANO, Nicola. História da filosofia. v. 10. Trad. Armando da Silva Carvalho e Antônio Ramos Rosa. 2. ed. Lisboa: Editorial Presença, 1978. Título original: Storia dela filosofia.

ALEXY, Robert. On the concept and the nature of law. Ratio Juris, Oxford, v. 21, n. 3, p. 281-299, sept. 2008.

ALEXY, Robert. Teoria discursiva do direito. Org., Trad. e Estudo introdutório Alexandre Travessoni Gomes Trivisonno. Rio de Janeiro: Forense Universitária, 2014.

ARGÜELLES, Juan Ramón de Páramo. Estudio preliminar: John Austin, un jurista desolado. In: AUSTIN, John. El objeto de la jurisprudencia. Traducción y estudio preliminar de Juan Ramón de Páramo Argüelles. Madrid: Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, 2002.

p. Título original: The province of jurisprudence determined.

AUSTIN, John. A plea for the constitution. 2. ed. London: John Murray, 1859. 42 p. AUSTIN, John. Centralization. The Edinburgh Review: or critical journal, Edinburgh, v. 85, n. 171, p. 221-260, Jan./Apr. 1847.

AUSTIN, John. Disposition of property by will – Primogeniture. The Westminster Review, Londres, v. 2, n. 4, p. 503-553, jul./out. 1824.

AUSTIN, John. El objeto de la jurisprudencia. Traducción y estudio preliminar Juan Ramón de Páramo Argüelles. Madrid: Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, 2002. 338 p. Título original: The province of jurisprudence determined.

AUSTIN, John. Joint Stock Companies. Parliamentary History and Review, London, p. 709-727, 1826.

AUSTIN, John. Lectures on jurisprudence: or, the philosophy of positive law. 5. ed. rev. and edited by Robert Campbell. London: John Murray, 1911. v. 1.

AUSTIN, John. Lectures on jurisprudence: or, the philosophy of positive law. 5. ed. rev. and edited by Robert Campbell. London: John Murray, 1885. v. 2.

AUSTIN, John. List on the principles of the German Customs-Union. The Edinburgh Review: or critical journal, Edinburgh, v. 75, n. 152, p. 515-556, Apr./July 1842.

AUSTIN, John. The province of Jurisprudence determined: and the uses of the study of Jurisprudence. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1998. 396 p. (Hackett Classics Series)

AUSTIN, Sarah. Preface. In: AUSTIN, John. Lectures on jurisprudence: or, the philosophy of positive law. 3. ed. rev. and edited by Robert Campbell. London: John Murray, 1869. v. 1.

BOBBIO, Norberto. O positivismo jurídico: lições de filosofia do direito. Compiladas por Nello Morra. Tradução de Márcio Pugliesi, Edson Bini e Carlos E. Rodrigues. São Paulo: Ícone, 2006. 239 p. (Coleção elementos de direito)

CAMPBELL, Tom. El sentido del positivismo jurídico. Trad. Ángeles Ródenas. Doxa: Cuadernos de filosofía del derecho, Alicante, n. 25, p. 303-331, 2002.

DAVID, René. O direito inglês. Tradução de Eduardo Brandão. Revisão de Isabella Soares Micali. São Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2000. 120 p. Título original: Le droit anglais.

DIMOULIS, Dimitri. Positivismo jurídico: introdução a uma teoria do direito e defesa do pragmatismo jurídico-político. São Paulo: Método, 2006. 301 p. Coleção Profesor Gilmar Mendes.

GIFIS, Steven H. Law dictionary. 6. ed. New York: Barron’s Educational Series, 2010. 595 p.

HAMBURGER, Lotte; HAMBURGER, Joseph. Troubles lives: John and Sarah Austin. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1985. 261 p.

HART, H. L. A. Introduction. In: AUSTIN, John. The province of Jurisprudence determined: and the uses of the study of Jurisprudence. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1998. 396 p. (Hackett Classics Series)

HART, H. L. A. O conceito de direito. Pós-escrito org. por Penelope A. Bulloch e Joseph Raz. Trad. Antônio de Oliveira Sette-Câmara. Rev. Trad. Marcelo Brandão Cipolla. Rev. tec. Luiz Vergílio Dalla-Rosa. São Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2009. 399 p. Título original: The concepto of law.

HART, H. L. A. O positivismo e a separação entre o direito e a moral. In: Hart, Herbert L. A. Ensaios sobre teoria do direito e filosofia. Trad. José Garcez Ghirardi e Lenita Maria Rimoli Esteves. Rev. tec. Ronaldo Porto Macedo Junior e Leonardo Gomes Penteado Rosa. Rio de Janeiro: Elsevier, 2010. (Teoria e filosofia do Direito)

HOERSTER, Norbert. En defensa del positivismo jurídico. Trad. Ernesto Garzón Valdés. Rev. Ruth Zimmerling. Barcelona: Gedisa, 2000.

MAINE, Henry Sumner. Lectures on the early history of institutions. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 1875. 412 p.

MANSILLA, Isabel Turégano. Derecho y moral em John Austin. Madrid: Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, 2001. 562 p. (Colección el Derecho y la Justicia)

MILL, John Stuart. Autobiografia. Tradução de Alexandre Braga Massella. São Paulo: Iluminuras, 2006. 253 p. Título original: Autobiography.

MILL, John Stuart. O utilitarismo. Trad. e Introdução Alexandre Braga Massella. São Paulo: Iluminuras, 2000. 94 p. Título original: the utilitarism.

MORESO, José Juan. El positivismo jurídico y la aplicación del derecho. DOXA: Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho, Alicante, n. 27, p. 45-62, 2004.

MORISON, William L. John Austin. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1982. 239 p. (Jurists: profiles in legal theory).

RAZ, Joseph. The authority of law: essas on law and morality. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979. 289 p.

REALE, Giovanni; ANTISERI, Dario. História da filosofia: do romantismo ao empiriocriticismo. v. 5. Trad. Ivo Storniolo. Revisão Zolferino Tonon. São Paulo: Paulus, 2005. Título original: Storia dela filosofia: v. III, Dal romanticismo ai nostri gioni.

ROSS, Janet. Three generations of english women: memoirs and correspondence of Susannah Taylor, Sarah Austin and Lady Duff Gordon 2. ed. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1893. 571 p.

RUMBLE, Wilfried E. Doing Austin Justice: the reception of John Austin’s philosophy of law in nineteenth-century England. London; New York: Continuum, 2005. 270 p.

RUMBLE, Wilfried E. The thought of John Austin: Jurisprudence, Colonial Reform, and the British Constitution. London: Athlone Press; Dover: New Hampshire, 1985. 278 p.